We recommend these hotel chains because of our personal experiences staying at them. These companies have not paid us to recommend them and we do not receive any commissions or booking fees. No hotelier can request to be included on this page. We reserve the right to change these listings at our discretion.
What is a High-quality Budget Hotel?
In 2017 there is a significant difference in quality of service and stay between a motel that charges you $30 per night versus a hotel that charges you $300 per night. Nonetheless, the travel accommodation industry has different levels of service and price that confuse the average traveler. Even within the same chain there are hotels of varying quality and price.
Our criteria are simple. We want to stay in hotels that are:
- Reasonably priced
- Very comfortable, clean, and modern in design
- Easy to reach
- Located in safe areas
A “reasonable price” could be anything from $59 a night to $150 a night in 2017 dollars. In most cases we have found good rooms at very nice hotels in the $89 to $110 price range. It’s hard to argue that these are “budget” prices but we’re looking at the very best travel experiences for less than typical business rates. And yet good hotels rarely offer the same rates all the time. Here is an example of available booking prices from a Courtyard by Marriott over a two-week period.

Some chains may offer better rates more often than others. Some chains may lack certain amenities that the most volatile hotel companies provide. So our definition of “budget” must be fluid. Typically, the farther in advance you book a hotel room, the more likely you are to get a better rate. But sometimes you can get the best rates at the last minute just by pure dumb luck.
“Comfortable, clean, and modern” means exactly what it says. A hotel that was built 30-50 years ago, unless heavily renovated, suffers in quality by comparison with hotels built within the last 10-15 years. Modern rooms tend to be more spacious with more comfortable bathroom facilities. If the hotel you are booking looks like it was used to film a scene in the original “Terminator” movie, it is too old to fall into our “comfortable, clean, and modern” category.
Budget hotel chains often showcase their very best (and oftentimes most expensive) locations in their advertising. Take Best Western, for example. All the hotels are independently owned. Some of them are luxury hotels. Most of them are lower-end budget hotels, many of which were built decades ago.
The aged design and appearance of hotel rooms doesn’t mean you’ll get bad service or stay in a flea-infested nightmare. But it does mean you are sacrificing a standard of quality to shave $10-30 off the price of a single night’s stay. There are some better options. You just need to do a little research.
“Easy to reach” and “located in safe areas” are often closely related. Many older hotels that are located in high-crime areas are a little off the beaten path, but not always. In fact, in the north Atlanta metro area there are two hotels from the same chain located just two blocks from each other. Both are reached by the same Interstate highway exit. One of the hotels is well-regarded by business travelers. The other looks like it is used by crime conventions.
Good, safe hotels are usually located close to Interstate highways, major 4-lane state highways, airports, convention centers, and shopping malls. But if the neighborhood in which they are located looks older, less successful then the hotels are less likely to be newer or newly renovated hotels. Hoteliers invest new money in areas where they expect a lot of business. The most business comes from neighborhoods that make people feel safe.
Our Short List of Recommended High-quality Budget Hotels
We will keep this list updated on at least an annual basis. We don’t expect to make many changes. We do realize that levels of quality vary for any number of reasons, but these are hotels where we have stayed at several locations with reasonable satisfaction in the past 10 years.
In some areas these hotels may be priced above other, equally acceptable hotels. Just because a chain is on our short list does not mean we would not consider staying at a different hotel in the same area. These are our first and second choices for budget hotels but only as long as they don’t sacrifice quality or charge higher prices than we expect. Any room priced under $100 a night is within our target range. But we do like to negotiate passively by looking at what the competition has to offer.
First Choice Hotels
Courtyard by Marriott – This is a higher-priced business traveler hotel but in some areas the Courtyard by Marriott room rates can drop below $100 a night. These hotels usually have a restaurant but you can frequently dine out at nearby restaurants, too.
La Quinta Inn & Suites – There are two styles of La Quinta hotels: “La Quinta” and “La Quinta Inn & Suites”. We prefer to stay at the “Inn & Suites” variety. It has simply proven to be a more satisfying experience for us. La Quinta supposedly competes with Hilton’s Hampton Inn, Marriott’s Fairfield Inn, and Holiday Inn Express but those hotels all tend to be, in our experience, way over-priced. Their rooms are a little more plush than La Quinta’s but, let’s face it, you just need a place to relax and sleep while you are traveling.
Residence Inn (owned by Marriott) – Believe it or not, these extended stay hotels can be very comfortable and affordable but prices vary by location. You may have to think in terms of staying for a week or a month but as vacation rentals these are much better than weedy old cabins in the woods. We have confirmed there are still some locations near large cities that charge less than $100 per night but on average these hotels are more expensive than La Quinta Inn & Suites.
Second Choice Hotels
Candlewood Suites – These are higher-end extended stay hotels but sometimes you can find a deal for less than $100 per night. Intercontinental Hotel Group owns and operates Candlewood Suites. This is the same company that owns Crowne Plaza and Holiday Inn.
Country Inn and Suites — These hotels are not located in all markets but they appear to offer the same level of quality that we look for. None of our writing staff have stayed in any of these hotels. Look for locations that get great reviews from travel site members. Country Inn and Suites is owned and operated by Carlson Rezidor Hotel Group, the same company that operates the Radisson brands.
Doubletree Hotels – These are better-quality hotels than the usual roadside inns but their prices are reasonable. You may also be able to get great deals if you name your own price but that can be tricky. We have found that Doubletree doesn’t award points for some online reservations.
Extended Stay America – These hotels do charge more than $100 a night in many locations. Also, quite a few of their facilities are older but we have noticed they have an upgrade program. You can do much worse than rent one of their suites, especially in crowded venues near theme parks, casinos, and other high-demand areas.
Townplace Suites (owned by Marriott) – Another extended stay solution from Marriott, the Townplace Suites chain is really modern and comfortable, almost plush. They are not as numerous as Residence Inn and may be a little pricey but in some areas you may find a better, safer deal with Townplace Suites than with the lower-end $40-a-night specials. Also, Marriott has a rewards program that may help you save some money.